The extraordinary life of a brilliant woman whose contributions to science have been lied about and misused, the Henrietta Lacks of psychoanalysis, and whose mental health struggles look different in light of newly emerging research. In 1880, young Bertha Pappenheim got sick, she lost her ability to control her voice and her body. She was treated by Sigmund Freud’s mentor, Josef Breuer, who diagnosed her with “hysteria.” Together, Pappenheim and Breuer developed what she called “the talking cure”, talking out memories so that symptoms go away & this, Freud acknowledged, became the basis for what would become the theory of psychoanalysis. In Freud’s mythology Pappenheim was renamed “Anna O,” and as he got older his stories about her became more extreme. For over a century, scholars have wondered: Was she really sick? Was talking cure really a cure? Amid all this argument a persistent absence has remained: the actual woman, Bertha Pappenheim. Brownstein’s book fills this void, and more. Brownstein gives us the real Pappenheim, a brilliant feminist thinker, a crusader against human trafficking & a pioneer in her own right, in the hustling & heady world of 19th century Vienna. At the same time, he tells a parallel story that is playing out in leading medical centers today, about patients who suffer symptoms very much like Pappenheim’s & about the doctors who are trying to cure them, the story of the neuroscience of a condition now called FND. This is a book about science and history and psychology, about the relations of men and women, of body and mind, but perhaps most of all it’s about the medical art of listening, attending to patients long enough to acknowledge the reality of their pain.
